Showing posts with label blinkered academics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blinkered academics. Show all posts

Monday, 6 January 2014

Art & catastrophe, & BBC Alba documentary, repeated on 6 and 13 January

The BBC Alba 'Toxic Tiredness' documentary from January 2012 is being repeated tonight at 9pm*. The Gaelic parts are, of course, subtitled. I previously blogged about both episodes here (part one) and here (part two). I appear in episode one right at the beginning looking like a bag lady, with my usually rather funky prescription sunglasses - they filmed us at weird angles outside for a few shots, the effect is alienating and disorienting, maybe that was the intention. And then at approx - 2.30, 7:30, 13, 18:30, 24, 29, 40:50 and 48 mins (I talk about the novel here and read an extract).

And Professor Peter Behan, the consultant neurologist who diagnosed me in 1983/84, appears in episode two, 35 mins in. He is magnificent. I especially liked:

  '... there is an essential biochemical component to the illness which needs to be elucidated, and research should be along the grounds into these illnesses rather than dealing with psychological talk the talk nonsense'

Dr Charles Shepherd  of the ME Association - also diagnosed by Peter Behan -  makes a great contribution too (though I don't necessarily agree with *everything* he says). The early-mid eighties was still a hard time to get a diagnosis, it took me almost 18 months, but  the psychobabble that we know today was yet to reach its dizzying heights of obfuscation -  this conflation of  serious neuroimmune illness with 'chronic fatigue' has, as we know only too well, done untold damage. We can only hope that science is now progressing, albeit slowly, unfettered by the hijackers. Here's to some decent biomedical research in 2014.

* Part 1 repeated Tuesday 7th at 10pm and soon on iPlayer

*

And I came across these wonderful photos by Penny Clare the other day on the Centre for Medical Humanities blog. She took them while severely affected and bedridden. I particularly like A fingernail celebrates New Year (I don't want to breach copyright so am not posting any photos here).

 More of Penny's photos can be seen on the excellent Phoenix Rising site.


For me, these photos highlight the link between creativity and illness, we are 'forced' by the illness into places we never knew we would go. We are still ourselves but catastrophe has given us a different way of expression. I often think of my novel/fiction as  my response to catastrophe. Writing often is.

Friday, 23 August 2013

A couple of good things, a couple of bad things

Yesterday, I returned the dreadful Hystories by Elaine Showalter to the library, what a relief to have that book out of my possession, her cavalier dismissal of neuroimmune illness is simply bizarre. I can't even be bothered to talk about it any more, I tweeted a few times about it last week. I also discovered that local libraries stock food recycling/compost bags, so was very happy as I have just used up the ones the council provided a few months ago up. I was hoping to take out Claire Messud's The Woman Upstairs, but I could not remember her name, I was furious with my stupid head - and it does feel like a kind of stupidity, this cognitive bleakness caused by ME - not the normal 'can't remember what I came in for', more like a database being erased from your head - spaces where facts should be: I was trying to remember her husband's name too, as a way back to her, I knew he was a critic - James Wood - and by the time I remembered, the library was closing... And not only can I now tell the difference between a herring gull and a lesser black-backed, I've learned there is such a thing as a red admiral butterfly *and* a small tortoiseshell. I thought tortoiseshells were only a kind of cat. You live and learn.

Monday, 18 July 2011

Storytelling (2)

Truly disheartening to see 'chronic fatigue syndrome' - unforgivably and ignorantly - referenced as a modern form of hysteria by Asti Hustvedt in her book Medical Muses - this from Guardian reviewer:

This turns Hustvedt's book into a study of how the diagnosis of illness can be chosen, a negotiation between doctor and patient. With a nod to contemporary life, Hustvedt points out that "no drug exists to cure anorexia, bulimia, self-mutilation, chronic fatigue syndrome and multiple personality disorder and no genetic flaw has been found to explain them. Furthermore, as was true for hysteria, these contemporary disorders are thought to be contagious, spread by suggestion, imitation and therapy."

It would appear she needed some juicy 21st century illnesses to compare to late 19th century 'hysteria', and lazy googling led her to believe that 'chronic fatigue syndrome' fits the bill. Of course, one is immediately reminded of the dreadful Elaine Showalter. A shame she (Hustvedt) hadn't been more diligent in her research, her book sounds like it might have been interesting, but this juxtaposition of chronic fatigue syndrome with anorexia and self-mutilation and multiple personality disorder is simply alarming.

More here.

It also made me think of the novel The Story of Marie and Blanche by Per Olov Enquist, about which I wrote a few lines a few years ago. Am sure certain medics (and a certain academic) would still love to get out the ovarian compressors for women with ME. Maybe the NICE guidelines can add the compressors to CBT and GET?

Tuesday, 1 December 2009

Books I will never read, and one you should read

I will never read Going Rogue, obviously, but I enjoyed this review.

I'm always curious about lists of writers' favourite books but was peeved to see a recommendation for a recent book ('sympathetic, informed, canny') by Elaine Showalter. The book may well deserve such praise from Joyce Carol Oates (they are friends, I believe), but I have not read - and will never read - anything by Showalter for I cannot see her name without feeling huge anger and disrespect. (For those who don't know, in 1997, she wrote Hystories: Hysterical Epidemics and Modern Media in which she irresponsibly and shamefully argued that ME and Gulf War Syndrome - like claims of alien abduction - were manifestations of hysteria, 'psychogenic syndromes of the 1990s'. She was most certainly not sympathetic, informed or canny back then. I doubt she would get away with such assertions now, and one can only wish the aliens had abducted her before she got away with it in 1997.)

I just finished Mark Steel's What's Going On?, I've been dipping into it for a couple of months, it made me laugh out loud, though melancholy at times.